Independent Insurance Agency · Garden City, NY

Insurance that actually has your back.

Stratford Insurance is Garden City’s independent agency — real local advice on auto, home, life, and business coverage, with claims help around the clock.

Licensed NY AgencyFree Quotes24/7 Claims Help
15+ carriers

We shop the market so you don’t have to.

Local humans

A real neighbor answers when you call.

Scroll

Welcome

Garden City’s trusted insurance agency.

Stratford Insurance started with a storefront on Stewart Avenue and a belief that insurance should come with a person attached — someone who knows your street, your house, and your name.

Our story →

Inside Stratford Insurance

What we do

Everything you need, under one roof.

Stratford Insurance has served Garden City and surrounding Long Island towns for years with honest work and clear pricing.

01

Auto Insurance

Coverage that fits how you actually drive — commuters, families, and new drivers.

  • Liability & collision
  • Roadside add-ons
  • Safe-driver discounts

02

Homeowners Insurance

Protect the biggest investment you’ll ever make, down to the fine print.

  • Dwelling & contents
  • Liability protection
  • Water backup options

03

Life Insurance

Simple, honest guidance on term and permanent policies for every budget.

  • Term life
  • Whole life
  • Free needs analysis

04

Business Insurance

From Main Street shops to contractors — coverage that grows with you.

  • General liability
  • Workers’ comp
  • Commercial auto

05

Umbrella Policies

An extra layer of liability protection for a few hundred dollars a year.

  • $1M+ coverage
  • Home + auto bundled
  • Affordable peace of mind

06

Flood & Specialty

Long Island living means water risk. We cover what standard policies don’t.

  • Flood insurance
  • Jewelry & valuables
  • Renters policies
0Policies in force*
0Years serving Nassau*
0Carrier partners*
0Clients who renew*

* Illustrative figures for this concept demo — ask us for the real numbers when we talk.

The difference

See what Stratford can do.

Underinsured
Fully protected
↔
Underinsured Fully protected

One storm is all it takes.

How it works

Simple from first call to finish.

Free quote

Tell us what you have — or what you’re worried about.

We shop 15+ carriers

Independent means we compare, not push one company.

Pick your coverage

Clear options, plain English, no pressure.

We’re here at claim time

One call, day or night — we walk it through with you.

Kind words

Neighbors who trust us.

★★★★★
“They found me better coverage for $600 less a year — and explained every line of the policy.”
— Homeowner, Garden City
★★★★★
“When a pipe burst at 2am, one call to Stratford had an adjuster on it by morning.”
— Homeowner, Hempstead
★★★★★
“Finally, an agent who picks up the phone. My whole family’s policies are here now.”
— Driver, Mineola

Testimonials are illustrative examples for this concept demo.

Questions

Asked all the time.

We represent 15+ carriers, not one. That means we shop your coverage every year and move you when a better value appears — a captive agent can’t do that.

Yes — bundling is usually the fastest way to cut 10–25% off both policies, and we handle all the paperwork.

Both. Call for a 10-minute quote, or send your current declarations page and we’ll comparison-shop it for free.

Safe driver, good student, home security systems, paid-in-full, and loyalty discounts are the big ones — we check every policy for all of them.

Call us any time — day, night, weekends. We open the claim with the carrier and stay on it with you until it’s resolved.

Yes — all of Nassau County and western Suffolk, including Hempstead, Mineola, Westbury, and Uniondale.

Service area

Proudly serving Garden City & beyond.

Ready when you are.

One call is all it takes. Talk to a real person at Stratford Insurance today — free consultation, zero pressure.

☎ Call (516) 489-7129